Best Religion Nonprofits in Steubenville, OH (2026)
We scored Steubenville religion organizations that file a full IRS Form 990. 5 met our bar, 1 earned the America's Best designation, and 7 more are listed below with the reason they aren't ranked (1 scored below the bar, 6 without a score).
The top-ranked religion organization in Steubenville, OH is Daughters of Holy Mary of the Heart of Jesus, with an America's Best Score of 95 out of 100.
Last updated Nov 20, 2026 · Based on Form 990 filings through tax year 2025 · How we rank
-
1
Daughters of Holy Mary of the Heart of Jesus Religion · Revenue $555K (FY2025) · exempt since 201495SCOREAMERICA'S BEST 2026hsmcj.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves316.2 moTypical margin+36.3%Spend growth+42.1%/yr
-
2
St Paul Center for Biblical Theology Religion · Revenue $20.06M (FY2025) · exempt since 200286SCOREstpaulcenter.com ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves20.2 moTypical margin+40.1%Spend growth+29.2%/yr
-
3
Dietrich Von Hildebrand Legacy Project Religion · Revenue $729K (FY2024) · exempt since 200486SCOREhildebrandproject.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves35.6 moTypical margin+7.7%Spend growth+2.5%/yr
-
4
Hilltop Childrens House Religion · Revenue $333K (FY2025) · exempt since 201871SCOREhilltopchildrenshouse.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves10.5 moTypical margin+13.1%Spend growth+25.7%/yr
-
5
Messy Family Project Religion · Revenue $915K (FY2025) · exempt since 201870SCOREmessyfamilyproject.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves4.3 moTypical margin+5.5%Spend growth+15.0%/yr
Compare the ranked organizations
| # | Organization | Score | Revenue | Reserves | Typical margin | Exempt since | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Daughters of Holy Mary of the Heart of Jesus | 95 | $555K | 316.2 mo | +36.3% | 2014 | hsmcj.org |
| 2 | St Paul Center for Biblical Theology | 86 | $20.06M | 20.2 mo | +40.1% | 2002 | stpaulcenter.com |
| 3 | Dietrich Von Hildebrand Legacy Project | 86 | $729K | 35.6 mo | +7.7% | 2004 | hildebrandproject.org |
| 4 | Hilltop Childrens House | 71 | $333K | 10.5 mo | +13.1% | 2018 | hilltopchildrenshouse.org |
| 5 | Messy Family Project | 70 | $915K | 4.3 mo | +5.5% | 2018 | messyfamilyproject.org |
Listed, not ranked (7)
We show every organization we reviewed, and say why it isn't ranked: a score below 60, fewer than 2 full Form 990s on file, or an organization that mainly funds others (scored with foundations, not service providers).
Show all 7
| Organization | Why it isn't ranked |
|---|---|
| Mission to the Beloved | Score 36 |
| Community of Gods Love | Too few full 990s |
| Four Seasons Ministries | Too few full 990s |
| Fathers House Church | Too few full 990s |
| Benedict House | Too few full 990s |
| Good Soil Solutions | Too few full 990s |
| Elevated Parish Missions | Too few full 990s |