Backgroundthe Upper Midwest Law Center, founded in 2019 by dr. Douglas p. Seaton, is a non-partisan constitutional law firm that exists to protect fundamental rights, fight government overreach, and uphold the rule of law. In the last seven years, the firm has grown to seven litigators and three support staff. Umlc files landmark cases in cases involving schools, universities, the workplace, elect… Read more
Backgroundthe Upper Midwest Law Center, founded in 2019 by dr. Douglas p. Seaton, is a non-partisan constitutional law firm that exists to protect fundamental rights, fight government overreach, and uphold the rule of law. In the last seven years, the firm has grown to seven litigators and three support staff. Umlc files landmark cases in cases involving schools, universities, the workplace, election settings, union action, and even prisons. And we win, in state and federal court, achieving just outcomes that possess national precedential value. Representative cases in 2025minnesota gun owners caucus v. Walzin February 2025, umlc, on behalf of the Minnesota gun owners caucus, filed a lawsuit challenging key provisions of Minnesota's 2024 omnibus bill as unconstitutional. The case challenged the massive, last-minute law, as it violated the constitution's single subject clause and imposed major business mandates without proper legislative review. The court of appeals in 2026 ultimately affirmed a favorable trial court decision in all respects, striking down the binary trigger ban as a violation of the single subject clause but declining to invalidate any more of the 2024 omnibus bill in this case. It appears that the state of Minnesota has declined to seek Minnesota supreme court review of that decision. This means that the case is over and the state is permanently enjoined from enforcing the binary trigger ban. This case is an important recognition of respect for the constitution.schmitt v. Rebertusumlc brought this case against the Minnesota department of corrections after they discontinued the st. Cloud state prison's most popular program because its "Biblical lens" conflicted with the doc's "diversity, equity, and inclusivity" values. In August of 2025, we successfully obtained one of the best religious liberty decisions ever written by the eighth circuit on our motion for a preliminary injunction. After discovery, we settled this case in 2026 on very favorable terms, with tony schmitt able to teach his course at st. Cloud prison as he wishes for the long-term. This case is a deeply meaningful win for religious freedom.scott v. [National pharmacy] and the board of pharmacyin August 2025, umlc filed suit on behalf of two pharmacists who had longstanding religious accommodations revoked by a national pharmacy that claimed that board of pharmacy regulations did not permit the accommodation. We sued under the first amendment and title vii. We have settled with the national pharmacy on favorable and largely confidential terms, and our pharmacist clients will soon be back at work with a religious accommodation as of 2026. This case protects the religious liberties of employees asserting their constitutional and statutory rights.zahn v. Prior lake-savage area schoolsin August 2025, we filed suit for our client brooke zahn, a longtime public school teacher. Mrs. Zahn's employer, a public school district, violated her first amendment rights by disciplining her for her somewhat satirical and personal facebook post regarding deportation policy ("a family that is deported together stays together."). The case is ongoing and was brought to protect free speech rights of public employees.huizenga v. Independent school district no. 11Umlc filed suit to challenge a collective bargaining agreement that allows teachers to take a collective 100 paid days per year to work for the union, which then engages in political and campaign advocacy. School district residents alleged that this arrangement violates the free speech clause by forcing them to subsidize the union's political speech. In a major victory for taxpayers, the united states court of appeals for the eighth circuit in August 2025 reversed a lower court's decision, ruling that residents have the legal standing to challenge a public school district's practice of subsidizing a teachers union's political activities. The court held that the unconstitutional spending of taxpayer money is itself a legally protected injury, and that taxpayers do not need to show an overall "depletion of the public fisc" to have standing to sue.the decision is the Upper Midwest Law Center's second victory on a technical issue in this case. It now reinstates a lawsuit brought on behalf of taxpayers against the anoka-hennepin school district and a teachers union, sending it back to the U.S. District court in Minnesota to be heard on its constitutional merits.tayah lackie vs. Minnesota state university student association, inc. D/b/a students unitedas a student at st. Cloud university, tayah lackie was forced to fund speech with which disagreed, in violation of her first amendment rights, by students united, a private corporation created for the purpose of engaging in political speech, including highly contested policies and legislation. Students united purports to speak on behalf of all students, but in fact operates as a private political organization. In 2024, umlc filed suit on behalf of ms. Lackie to challenge Minnesota's requirement that students at the seven Minnesota state universities pay mandatory student fees to students united. In July 2025, the federal district court ruled that students united, although it is a private organization, can be held accountable for violating students' first amendment rights by working with the government to force students to fund political speech, in a win for transparency and government accountability.cajune et al. V. Independent school district 194 et al.in April 2025, umlc celebrated a favorable settlement in a case challenging lakeville schools' policy of permitting Black lives matter posters while prohibiting other political expressions, including "all lives matter and "blue lives matter" posters.filed in 2022, the lawsuit argued that the school district's selective policy violated the first amendment rights of the plaintiffs, parents and their minor school student children, by engaging in unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination. In June 2024, the eighth circuit court of appeals reversed an unfavorable district court decision, ruling that the lakeville school district could not classify the display of Black lives matter posters as "government speech and that it had committed "impermissible viewpoint discrimination."with the eighth circuit's decision clearly signaling that the school district's policy was constitutionally unsound, lakeville schools wisely reversed their policy and removed the posters from district facilities. Because that was what the plaintiffs had sought in the lawsuit, they agreed to dismiss their claims in the settlement in return for the district paying $30,000 in legal fees to the Upper Midwest Law Center.sorcan v. Rock ridge school districtin 2023, the Upper Midwest Law Center filed a lawsuit against independent school district 2909 on behalf of board member pollyann sorcan for violating ms. Sorcan's first amendment rights. Ms. Sorcan would ask relevant but tough questions regarding policies before the board. The other board members grew frustrated by this and chose to retaliate against her speech and advocacy. On August 9, 2021, isd 2909 passed a resolution to censure ms. Sorcan based on unsupported misconduct allegations, limiting her free speech and access to committee meetings. Ms. Sorcan was not just censured she was also stripped of committee assignments, and the board attempted to bar her from even attending committee meetings to be informed of the board's business like any citizen. The board's actions prevented ms. Sorcan from effectively performing her duties as a board member.in March 2025, the U.S. Court of appeals for the eighth circuit reversed a lower court decision and held that local officials and school districts cannot dodge accountability for violating fellow board members' first amendment rights. The case is now winding its way back up to the eighth circuit following a second loss in the federal district court on the issue of cognizable harm.Minnesota voters alliance et al. V. Walz et al.in a major victory for election integrity and the rule of law, the Minnesota supreme court in January 2025 quashed governor walz's writ of election for house district 40b and cancelled the planned January 28, 2025, special election because governor walz issued the writ prematurely, contrary to Minnesota election law.the court's order granted the January 2025 petition filed by the Minnesota voters alliance (mva) and two petitioners, represented by umlc.