America's Best Nonprofits
  1. Home
  2. Arts & Culture
  3. Eustis, FL
  4. Bay Street Players

Bay Street Players

Bay Street Players has an America's Best Score of 35 out of 100, based on its 2025 Form 990, below the 60-point bar to be ranked.

  • Eustis, FL
  • Tax-exempt since 1990
  • EIN: 59-1789108
baystreetplayers.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
Is this your organization? Claim it Tax filings by year Nominate
35OF 100 Not ranked Below the 60-point bar How this score is calculated

Organization summary

Bay Street Players is a 501(c)(3) organization, classified under Arts & Culture (NTEE A650). Contributions are tax-deductible.

109 N Bay St, Eustis, FL 32726-3402

In fiscal year 2025 it reported $274,620 in revenue and $285,396 in expenses, with contributions making up 35.6% of revenue.

Work here? Claim this profile to add your mission, programs and logo.

What it does

From its own Form 990, as filed with the IRS

Mission · 2025 Form 990

Non-Profit Community Theatre in Lake County, Florida

Main program · fiscal year 2025

  • The 50th season for the Bay Street Players (bsp) ended well, though ticket sales were not nearly as strong as we had hoped. The management worked hard to keep costs down which helped to offset the lack of revenues. The next seasons shows should bring more patrons back to our historic theater.the bsp team again welcomed several new members to our board of directors, each of whom have a special conn… Read more

    The 50th season for the Bay Street Players (bsp) ended well, though ticket sales were not nearly as strong as we had hoped. The management worked hard to keep costs down which helped to offset the lack of revenues. The next seasons shows should bring more patrons back to our historic theater.the bsp team again welcomed several new members to our board of directors, each of whom have a special connection to the bsp community. These new members also bring skills which will improve our standing in the community.the season began with ken ludwigs comedy shakespeare in hollywood, followed by the popular man-eating plant musical little shop of horrors. Calendar 2025 began with the recently released, and possibly soon to be on the broadway stage drama paper thin. The final two productions of the main stage season were the dr. Seuss based production of seussical the musical, and we closed our season with a modernized version of the shakespeare show much ado about nothing. Young peoples theater (ypt) expanded to add a ypteen group for those youth aged 13-18. In the fall, they had dual casts performing little women, while youth 8-10 performed the surprising story of the three little pigs. Ypt followed the seussical production with their own production of seussical, jr in the srping. The summer saw the ypt production of the spongebob musical: Youth edition.the theater also began to add tribute bands and comedy shows, and hopes to expand on that in coming years.this season begins with the steve martin and edie brickell musical bright star, followed by the cult classic (relatively speaking) evil dead. January of 2026 begins with a mad max themed version of shakespeares king lear, followed by the lightning thief a percy jackson based musical, and we end our season with jimmy buffetts escape to margaritaville. While the building is 103, we are keeping our productions fresh and seek to bring many more modern choices for our patrons.

    $243,034 spent

Where each dollar went · fiscal year 2025

Of every dollar it spent, 85¢ went to programs, 8¢ to management and 7¢ to fundraising.

  • Programs $243,034
  • Management $21,183
  • Fundraising $21,179

In the organization's own words to the IRS, shown for context. None of this affects the America's Best Score, and a Form 990 describes programs without measuring their results.

America's Best Score

Free assessmentMethodology
Score35 / 100
DesignationNot ranked

Score breakdown

MeasureThis organizationPoints
Operating reserves-3.7 mo; 3.9 mo in cash0 / 25
Financial balance (median margin)−6.8%4.2 / 20
Transparency3 full 990s, latest TY202520 / 20
Program growth−14.1% / yr0.5 / 15
Track record36 years10 / 10
Debt load174.7% of assets0 / 10
Total34.7 → 35
Spending on programs
Not scored; America's Best needs 65%+
85%Meets

Tax filings by year

Financial data extracted from the Form 990 the organization filed with the IRS for each fiscal year. Revenue lines can exceed 100% when other items, such as fundraising event costs, are netted against total revenue.

Revenue$274,620Fiscal year 20252023: $307,23320232024: $298,49320242025: $274,6202025
Expenses$285,396Fiscal year 20252023: $386,29920232024: $320,22820242025: $285,3962025
Total assets$117,123Fiscal year 20252023: $42,08920232024: $23,03520242025: $117,1232025
Total liabilities$204,605Fiscal year 20252023: $97,23820232024: $99,74120242025: $204,6052025
Fiscal year ending August 2025
Revenue$274,620
Expenses$285,396
Net income−$10,776
Net assets−$87,482

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$97,790
Program services$176,102
Investment income$0
Other (net)$728

Assets / debt

Total assets$117,123
Total liabilities$204,605
Net assets−$87,482

Compensation

Not in our extract for this year.

Fiscal year ending August 2024
Revenue$298,493
Expenses$320,228
Net income−$21,735
Net assets−$76,706

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$85,461
Program services$212,663
Investment income$0
Other (net)$369

Assets / debt

Total assets$23,035
Total liabilities$99,741
Net assets−$76,706

Compensation

Not in our extract for this year.

Fiscal year ending August 2023
Revenue$307,233
Expenses$386,299
Net income−$79,066
Net assets−$55,149

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$37,500
Program services$263,203
Investment income$1
Other (net)$6,529

Assets / debt

Total assets$42,089
Total liabilities$97,238
Net assets−$55,149

Compensation

Officers and key employees$0
Share of expenses0.0%

About this data

Figures come from IRS Form 990 filings, through the IRS Exempt Organizations Business Master File (2026-11-09) and e-filed returns. Form 990 data typically lags 12–24 months behind an organization's fiscal year. Found an error?