America's Best Nonprofits
  1. Home
  2. Religion
  3. Nappanee, IN
  4. Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund

Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund

Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund is ranked among religion organizations in Nappanee, IN, with an America's Best Score of 63 out of 100, based on its 2025 Form 990.

  • Nappanee, IN
  • Tax-exempt since 2014
  • EIN: 35-1798265
ProPublica Charity Navigator
Is this your organization? Claim it Tax filings by year Nominate
63OF 100 Ranked in Nappanee Religion How this score is calculated

Organization summary

Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund is a 501(c)(3) organization, classified under Religion (NTEE X12). Contributions are tax-deductible.

8216 W 1350 N, Nappanee, IN 46550-8787

Among the 3 scored religion organizations in Nappanee, Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund holds 4.3 months of operating reserves (peer median 15 months), runs a typical yearly surplus of 11.0% (peers: surplus of 11.0%), and has grown spending 26.1% a year (peers: grown spending 21.6% a year).

In fiscal year 2025 it reported $5,371,181 in revenue and $4,811,715 in expenses, with contributions making up 0.0% of revenue.

Work here? Claim this profile to add your mission, programs and logo.

What it does

From its own Form 990, as filed with the IRS

Mission · 2025 Form 990

Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund is a church controlled organization whereby old order amish members invest funds which are channeled to those in need of borrowing funds to maintain the anabaptist religious beliefs, cultural traditions and lifestyles for residential real estate loans.

Main program · fiscal year 2025

  • Amish Mutual Mortgage Fund is a church controlled organization whereby old order amish members invest funds which are channeled to other old order amish church members which are in need of borrowing funds to maintain the anabaptist religious beliefs, cultural traditions and lifestyles for residential real estate loans. $4,738,674 spent

Where each dollar went · fiscal year 2025

Of every dollar it spent, 98¢ went to programs, 2¢ to management and 0¢ to fundraising.

  • Programs $4,738,674
  • Management $73,041
  • Fundraising $0

In the organization's own words to the IRS, shown for context. None of this affects the America's Best Score, and a Form 990 describes programs without measuring their results.

America's Best Score

Free assessmentMethodology
Score63 / 100
DesignationRanked

Score breakdown

MeasureThis organizationPoints
Operating reserves4.3 mo; 24.6 mo in cash3 / 25
Financial balance (median margin)+11.0%20 / 20
Transparency4 full 990s, latest TY202520 / 20
Program growth+26.1% / yr15 / 15
Track record12 years4.8 / 10
Debt load98.3% of assets0 / 10
Total62.8 → 63
Spending on programs
Not scored; America's Best needs 65%+
98%Meets

Compared with Nappanee peers

MeasureThis organizationPeer median
Operating reserves4.3 mo15.0 mo
Typical margin+11.0%+11.0%
Spending growth+26.1% / yr+21.6% / yr
Debt load98.3%43.8%

Peers: the 3 Nappanee religion organizations with a score, ranked or below the bar.

Tax filings by year

Financial data extracted from the Form 990 the organization filed with the IRS for each fiscal year. Revenue lines can exceed 100% when other items, such as fundraising event costs, are netted against total revenue.

Revenue$5,371,181Fiscal year 20252022: $2,543,95020222023: $4,468,19020232024: $4,902,25820242025: $5,371,1812025
Expenses$4,811,715Fiscal year 20252022: $2,402,08020222023: $3,899,14720232024: $4,445,18920242025: $4,811,7152025
Total assets$104,555,648Fiscal year 20252022: $91,576,74120222023: $91,190,87720232024: $93,677,45120242025: $104,555,6482025
Total liabilities$102,824,680Fiscal year 20252022: $91,314,70220222023: $90,476,44420232024: $92,505,94920242025: $102,824,6802025
Fiscal year ending December 2025
Revenue$5,371,181
Expenses$4,811,715
Net income$559,466
Net assets$1,730,968

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$0
Program services$4,591,071
Investment income$780,110
Other (net)$0

Assets / debt

Total assets$104,555,648
Total liabilities$102,824,680
Net assets$1,730,968

Compensation

Not in our extract for this year.

Fiscal year ending December 2024
Revenue$4,902,258
Expenses$4,445,189
Net income$457,069
Net assets$1,171,502

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$0
Program services$4,416,788
Investment income$485,450
Other (net)$20

Assets / debt

Total assets$93,677,451
Total liabilities$92,505,949
Net assets$1,171,502

Compensation

Not in our extract for this year.

Fiscal year ending December 2023
Revenue$4,468,190
Expenses$3,899,147
Net income$569,043
Net assets$714,433

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$0
Program services$3,991,691
Investment income$476,499
Other (net)$0

Assets / debt

Total assets$91,190,877
Total liabilities$90,476,444
Net assets$714,433

Compensation

Officers and key employees$53,793
Share of expenses1.4%
Fiscal year ending December 2022
Revenue$2,543,950
Expenses$2,402,080
Net income$141,870
Net assets$262,039

Notable sources of revenue

Percent of total revenue
Contributions$0
Program services$2,356,743
Investment income$186,697
Other (net)$510

Assets / debt

Total assets$91,576,741
Total liabilities$91,314,702
Net assets$262,039

Compensation

Officers and key employees$51,291
Share of expenses2.1%

About this data

Figures come from IRS Form 990 filings, through the IRS Exempt Organizations Business Master File (2026-11-09) and e-filed returns. Form 990 data typically lags 12–24 months behind an organization's fiscal year. Found an error?