- Home
- Animal Welfare
- New York
- Staten Island
Best Animal Welfare Nonprofits in Staten Island, NY (2026)
We scored Staten Island animal welfare organizations that file a full IRS Form 990. 4 met our bar, and 8 more are listed with the reason they aren't ranked (1 scored below the bar, 7 without a score).
The top-ranked animal welfare organization in Staten Island, NY is Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare, with an America's Best Score of 80 out of 100.
Last updated Nov 21, 2026 · Based on Form 990 filings through tax year 2025 · How we rank
-
1
Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare Animal Welfare · Revenue $318K (FY2025) · exempt since 197480SCOREsicawsaves.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves28.0 moTypical margin−8.5%Spend growth+24.4%/yr
-
2
Staten Island Zoological Society Animal Welfare · Revenue $5.95M (FY2025) · exempt since 194973SCOREstatenislandzoo.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves8.5 moTypical margin+9.4%Spend growth+4.8%/yr
-
3
P L U T O Pet Lovers United Together As One Rescue of Richmond Animal Welfare · Revenue $48K (FY2024) · exempt since 200165SCOREplutorescue.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves50.4 moTypical margin−51.8%Spend growth−14.5%/yr
-
4
Broken Souls Rescue and Recovery Animal Welfare · Revenue $794K (FY2024) · exempt since 202164SCOREpitbullsandaddicts.org ProPublica Charity NavigatorReserves3.1 moTypical margin+14.9%Spend growth+56.2%/yr
Compare the ranked organizations
| Organization | Rank | Score | Revenue | Reserves | Typical margin | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare | #1 | 80 | $318K | 28.0 mo | −8.5% | sicawsaves.org |
| Staten Island Zoological Society | #2 | 73 | $5.95M | 8.5 mo | +9.4% | statenislandzoo.org |
| P L U T O Pet Lovers United Together As One Rescue of Richmond | #3 | 65 | $48K | 50.4 mo | −51.8% | plutorescue.org |
| Broken Souls Rescue and Recovery | #4 | 64 | $794K | 3.1 mo | +14.9% | pitbullsandaddicts.org |
Listed, not ranked (8)
We show every organization we reviewed, and say why it isn't ranked: a score below 60, fewer than 2 full Form 990s on file, or an organization that mainly funds others (scored with foundations, not service providers).
| Organization | Why it isn't ranked |
|---|---|
| Near and Far Animal Foundation | Score 37 |
| Staten Island Hope Animal Rescue | Too few full 990s |
| Victory 4 the Voiceless Animal Rescue | Too few full 990s |
| Paw Stories | Too few full 990s |
| Strays Hope for Life Animal Rescue | Too few full 990s |
| Animal Awareness Abroad Foundation | Too few full 990s |
| Black Cat Society | Too few full 990s |
| For Blakes Sake Rescue | Too few full 990s |