America's Best Nonprofits
  1. Home
  2. Animal Welfare
  3. New York
  4. Staten Island

Best Animal Welfare Nonprofits in Staten Island, NY (2026)

We scored Staten Island animal welfare organizations that file a full IRS Form 990. 4 met our bar, and 8 more are listed with the reason they aren't ranked (1 scored below the bar, 7 without a score).

The top-ranked animal welfare organization in Staten Island, NY is Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare, with an America's Best Score of 80 out of 100.

Last updated Nov 21, 2026 · Based on Form 990 filings through tax year 2025 · How we rank

  1. 1
    Staten Island Council for Animal Welfare Animal Welfare · Revenue $318K (FY2025) · exempt since 1974
    Reserves28.0 mo
    Typical margin−8.5%
    Spend growth+24.4%/yr
    sicawsaves.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    80SCORE
  2. 2
    Staten Island Zoological Society Animal Welfare · Revenue $5.95M (FY2025) · exempt since 1949
    Reserves8.5 mo
    Typical margin+9.4%
    Spend growth+4.8%/yr
    statenislandzoo.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    73SCORE
  3. 3
    P L U T O Pet Lovers United Together As One Rescue of Richmond Animal Welfare · Revenue $48K (FY2024) · exempt since 2001
    Reserves50.4 mo
    Typical margin−51.8%
    Spend growth−14.5%/yr
    plutorescue.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    65SCORE
  4. 4
    Broken Souls Rescue and Recovery Animal Welfare · Revenue $794K (FY2024) · exempt since 2021
    Reserves3.1 mo
    Typical margin+14.9%
    Spend growth+56.2%/yr
    pitbullsandaddicts.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    64SCORE

Compare the ranked organizations

Listed, not ranked (8)

We show every organization we reviewed, and say why it isn't ranked: a score below 60, fewer than 2 full Form 990s on file, or an organization that mainly funds others (scored with foundations, not service providers).

OrganizationWhy it isn't ranked
Near and Far Animal FoundationScore 37
Staten Island Hope Animal RescueToo few full 990s
Victory 4 the Voiceless Animal RescueToo few full 990s
Paw StoriesToo few full 990s
Strays Hope for Life Animal RescueToo few full 990s
Animal Awareness Abroad FoundationToo few full 990s
Black Cat SocietyToo few full 990s
For Blakes Sake RescueToo few full 990s