1. Home
  2. Mental Health
  3. Indiana
  4. Carmel

Best Mental Health Nonprofits in Carmel, IN (2026)

We scored Carmel mental health organizations that file a full IRS Form 990. 4 met our bar, and 1 more are listed below with the reason they aren't ranked (0 scored below the bar, 1 without a score).

The top-ranked mental health organization in Carmel, IN is Arrow Consultation Services, with an America's Best Score of 68 out of 100.

Last updated Nov 21, 2026 · Based on Form 990 filings through tax year 2025 · How we rank

  1. 1
    Arrow Consultation Services Mental Health · Revenue $4.66M (FY2025) · exempt since 1992
    Reserves5.7 mo
    Typical margin−0.0%
    Spend growth+7.0%/yr
    ProPublica Charity Navigator
    68SCORE
  2. 2
    Aspire Indiana Mental Health · Revenue $44.22M (FY2024) · exempt since 1976
    Reserves10.3 mo
    Typical margin−5.8%
    Spend growth+14.4%/yr
    aspireindiana.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    64SCORE
  3. 3
    Bens Ranch Foundation Mental Health · Revenue $509K (FY2025) · exempt since 2016
    Reserves4.3 mo
    Typical margin+16.1%
    Spend growth+63.0%/yr
    bensranch.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    61SCORE
  4. 4
    New Shoe Day Foundation Mental Health · Revenue $292K (FY2025) · exempt since 2021
    Reserves4.8 mo
    Typical margin+19.4%
    Spend growth+40.6%/yr
    newshoeday.org ProPublica Charity Navigator
    60SCORE

Compare the ranked organizations

#OrganizationScoreRevenueReservesTypical marginExempt sinceWebsite
1Arrow Consultation Services68$4.66M5.7 mo−0.0%1992 —
2Aspire Indiana64$44.22M10.3 mo−5.8%1976 aspireindiana.org
3Bens Ranch Foundation61$509K4.3 mo+16.1%2016 bensranch.org
4New Shoe Day Foundation60$292K4.8 mo+19.4%2021 newshoeday.org

Listed, not ranked (1)

We show every organization we reviewed, and say why it isn't ranked: a score below 60, fewer than 2 full Form 990s on file, or an organization that mainly funds others (scored with foundations, not service providers).

Show all 1
OrganizationWhy it isn't ranked
Nick Lackey FoundationToo few full 990s