Benchmarks from IRS Form 990 data

Benchmarks: Mutual & Membership Benefit · Midwest

What's typical for nonprofits, from the latest Form 990 filings of every organization we score: 206,219 nationwide. Compare a cause, region or state with the country, and see where our score draws its lines and why.

Mutual & Membership Benefit · Midwest

39 scored nonprofits, 1 of them named America's Best. 79% spend at least 65% of their budget on programs. 36% hold more than 3 years of expenses in cash and savings.

Measure Typical Middle half U.S. typical What our score looks for Outside standard
Operating reserves
Net assets ÷ monthly expenses
65.5 mo 12.6 mo to 10+ yrs 10.4 mo Full points at 36 months —
Cash and savings
Cash and savings ÷ monthly expenses
10.9 mo 3.6 mo to 59.4 mo 4.7 mo Reserve points fade from 36 months, gone at 10 years BBB Wise Giving Alliance: no more than 3 years of expenses held in unrestricted net assets (Standard 10)
Yearly surplus
Revenue minus expenses, as a share of expenses
+20.6% −0.9% to +119.3% +4.0% Full points at +5% a year; fades above +50% —
Spending growth
Annual growth in total expenses
+6.8% −4.9% to +29.3% +7.4% Full points at +15% a year —
Debt
Liabilities ÷ total assets
0.0% 0.0% to 3.6% 4.7% Full points at 10% or less —
Spending on programs
Program services ÷ total expenses (Form 990 Part IX)
87% 71% to 99% 86% 65% or more to be named America's Best BBB Wise Giving Alliance: at least 65% of total expenses on programs (Standard 8)

"Typical" is the median: half of nonprofits are above it and half below. The middle half runs from the 25th to the 75th percentile.

By cause in Midwest

Cause Scored Reserves Cash Yearly surplus On programs Meet 65% programs
Animal Welfare 1,264 19.5 mo 5.6 mo +5.1% 90% 93%
Arts & Culture 3,969 20.5 mo 5.7 mo +4.2% 81% 81%
Civil Rights & Advocacy 371 9.8 mo 5.9 mo +5.5% 79% 82%
Community Improvement 1,915 14.2 mo 7.2 mo +5.3% 86% 85%
Crime & Legal 697 10.0 mo 5.0 mo +4.7% 85% 89%
Disease & Disorders 583 14.4 mo 6.8 mo +4.4% 81% 86%
Education 5,934 11.5 mo 4.8 mo +5.6% 87% 90%
Employment 682 10.1 mo 3.9 mo +3.3% 86% 92%
Environment 952 22.9 mo 8.0 mo +11.5% 82% 83%
Food & Nutrition 834 12.3 mo 5.1 mo +5.2% 92% 92%
Health Care 3,270 9.2 mo 2.9 mo +3.7% 85% 92%
Housing & Shelter 2,639 14.8 mo 3.0 mo 0.0% 85% 92%
Human Services 7,399 9.7 mo 3.6 mo +3.5% 86% 91%
International Affairs 868 9.1 mo 5.1 mo +2.8% 89% 91%
Medical Research 290 14.7 mo 7.7 mo +3.4% 83% 82%
Mental Health 1,293 7.1 mo 2.9 mo +2.9% 84% 88%
Mutual & Membership Benefit 39 65.5 mo 10.9 mo +20.6% 87% 79%
Philanthropy & Grantmaking 1,849 28.1 mo 7.9 mo +10.8% 88% 89%
Public Benefit 507 11.1 mo 6.2 mo +5.0% 85% 85%
Public Safety & Disaster Relief 555 29.3 mo 12.4 mo +11.3% 97% 91%
Recreation & Sports 2,975 9.3 mo 5.7 mo +5.2% 95% 94%
Religion 2,235 12.0 mo 4.5 mo +4.5% 88% 85%
Science & Technology 162 12.4 mo 4.2 mo +2.8% 80% 82%
Social Science 66 13.0 mo 5.8 mo +4.6% 84% 90%
Unknown 274 14.2 mo 5.1 mo +4.8% 88% 92%
Youth Development 1,357 10.1 mo 5.0 mo +4.4% 85% 88%

Typical (median) figures.

By region: mutual & membership benefit

Region Scored Reserves Cash Yearly surplus On programs Meet 65% programs
Northeast 41 22.4 mo 8.7 mo +5.7% 91% 88%
Midwest 39 65.5 mo 10.9 mo +20.6% 87% 79%
South 59 14.6 mo 9.0 mo +8.7% 89% 84%
West 36 18.8 mo 9.4 mo +5.5% 91% 96%

Typical (median) figures.

By state: mutual & membership benefit

State Scored Reserves Cash Yearly surplus On programs Meet 65% programs
California 21 12.9 mo 6.4 mo +5.0% — —

Typical (median) figures. 40 with fewer than 20 scored organizations not shown.

How these benchmarks work

  • Every organization we score is included, ranked or not, so the figures describe the whole field, not only the winners.
  • Each figure comes from the organization's latest full Form 990. Growth and surplus use up to its last four filings.
  • Not every return reports cash or a program/overhead split. Those figures cover only the returns that do.
  • Groups with fewer than 20 organizations aren't shown.
  • Where our score sets a line, we set it where this data and a published standard agree. Our reasoning.

Source: IRS Form 990 filings. Outside standards: BBB Wise Giving Alliance Standards for Charity Accountability.