1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. What it takes: New York

Guide · Public Safety & Disaster Relief · New York

What It Takes to Be One of America's Best Public Safety & Disaster Relief Nonprofits in New York

From IRS Form 990 filings · Updated November 21, 2026 · By 3nity

We scored 1,007 public safety & disaster relief nonprofits in New York from their own IRS filings. 467 met our bar, and 26 earned the America's Best designation (2.6% of those we scored). Here is what the winners have in common, by the numbers.

The short answer

The typical America's Best winner here holds 68.9 months of operating reserves, against 51.7 months for other ranked public safety & disaster relief nonprofits and 9.3 months for those below the bar. In a typical year it runs a surplus of 22.9%, and its spending changes by +13.7% a year. Its liabilities come to 1.3% of its assets.

Where winners pull ahead most: financial balance and operating reserves. On financial balance, winners earn 97% of the possible points on average; other ranked public safety & disaster relief nonprofits earn 64%. On operating reserves, winners earn 98% of the possible points on average; other ranked public safety & disaster relief nonprofits earn 80%.

Size isn't what wins. The median winner takes in $395K a year; the median for other ranked public safety & disaster relief nonprofits is $286K.

The lowest-scoring winner here has a score of 93. Every winner needs at least 85 and a place in the top 5% of public safety & disaster relief nationally, and at least 65% of spending on programs.

Winners compared

Medians, so one very large or very small organization can't skew them.

MeasureAmerica's BestOther rankedBelow the bar
Organizations26441115
Score94.977.449.6
Operating reserves68.9 mo51.7 mo9.3 mo
Typical yearly margin+22.9%+12.0%−2.6%
Spending growth per year+13.7%+5.3%−4.4%
Share of spending on programs89.8%93.4%92.2%
Liabilities ÷ assets1.3%1.0%13.2%
Yearly revenue$395K$286K$213K

Points earned, part by part

Average points on each part of the 100-point score.

PartPossibleAmerica's BestOther ranked
Operating reserves2524.519.9
Financial balance2019.312.8
Program growth1513.29.6
Transparency2020.019.4
Track record108.86.9
Debt load109.88.7

How to get there

The score uses only what an organization reports to the IRS, so every point can be earned. Full points on each part take:

  • Operating reserves (25 points): net assets covering 36 months of expenses. Reserves are the biggest single part. But more isn't always better: once cash and savings pass 36 months of expenses, these points fade, and they're gone at 10 years. Money held far beyond need isn't serving the mission.
  • Financial balance (20): a surplus of 5.0% or more every year, but not above about 50% year after year. Each year counts, so one strong year can't make up for weak ones.
  • Program growth (15): spending that grows about 15.0% a year, a sign the work is expanding. Shrinking 15.0% a year or more earns nothing.
  • Transparency (20): at least 3 full Form 990s on file, the latest within 2 years. Filing the short 990-EZ or 990-N doesn't count toward this.
  • Track record (10): years since IRS recognition, full at 25 years.
  • Debt load (10): liabilities at or under 10.0% of total assets; at 60.0% or more, no points.
  • Spending on programs (not scored, but required): to be named America's Best, at least 65% of total spending has to go to programs, the BBB Wise Giving Alliance's standard.

See how public safety & disaster relief nonprofits compare by state and cause on the benchmarks page.

Want to see your own numbers against these? Get a free assessment: it shows your score on every part and the changes that would move it most.

The top 10 here

  1. Newton Abbot Fire Company · Blasdell, NY · score 100 · 44.9 mo reserves
  2. Gerry Volunteer Fire Dept · Gerry, NY · score 99 · 52.5 mo reserves
  3. Mombasha Fire Company of Monroe N Y · Monroe, NY · score 99 · 82.4 mo reserves
  4. Rye Volunteer Fire Fighters · Rye, NY · score 99 · 41.4 mo reserves
  5. Duane Volunteer Fire Company · Malone, NY · score 98 · 112.5 mo reserves
  6. Livingston Pumper No 1 · Livingston, NY · score 97 · 118.1 mo reserves
  7. Croton Falls Volunteer Fire Department · Croton Falls, NY · score 96 · 92.6 mo reserves
  8. Baldwinsville Vol Fire · Baldwinsville, NY · score 96 · 84.5 mo reserves
  9. Enterprise Fire Company No 1 of Phoenix Ny · Phoenix, NY · score 96 · 62.0 mo reserves
  10. Frontier Volunteer Fire · Niagara Falls, NY · score 95 · 108.8 mo reserves

See all 26 winners →

Where the winners are

How New York compares with the national picture →

Figures cover public safety & disaster relief organizations that file a full Form 990, and are recalculated each night from the latest filings. How we rank.